If you missed it, it was a reflection on the late Bishop James Pike and the late William Stringfellow, the lawyer and lay theologian who defended the Bishop at the Episcopal Church’s heresy trial.

Bishop James A. Pike (February 14, 1913 - September 1969)

It was a crazy week.I should rather say…I was a little crazy last week…in the sense that Bishop James Pike was a little crazy the night he walked down the hotel corridor in the altogether to knock on his friend William Stringfellow’s door at 4:00 in the morning.

According to the story, as told by Bill Stringfellow, the knock on his door awakened him from a sound sleep.

He opened the door to see the Bishop stark naked with a book in his hand. “Bill, you have to hear this! This is amazing!” The Bishop was oblivious to his nakedness. He plopped down in a chair and proceeded to tell his lawyer and his friend what he thought he had just discovered about Jesus in the wilderness. When he had shared the information, we wandered back down the hallway to his own room with his nose stuck in the book.

James Pike had become obsessed with Jesus in the wilderness. So absorbed in the Gospel accounts that he ate, drank, and slept them. His naked self was in those stories. Something about the wilderness temptations of Jesus consumed his total attention.

James Pike died sometime later in the Judean wilderness where the Gospels say Jesus spent 40 days and 40 nights. The date of his death is known only as the month of September in the year 1969, about the same time that I met Bill Stringfellow.

Why do I tell this story now? I was a little like the Bishop last week with the story of Barabbas. I get like that sometimes. I’ve remembered to pull my pants on to take the dogs for a walk, but in every other way, I can identify with the completeness of James Pike’s attention to the biblical story. I’m a little ”nuts” – with apologies to everyone who knows better than to use that kind of pejorative language to describe a state of mental illness.

I write this today not to arrive at your door in the altogether to tell you what I think I’ve discovered about Barabbas. I write quite simply because I miss the likes of Bishop Pike and Bill Stringfellow. I feel the need to honor the sacred memory of two very strange saints, one of them (the Bishop) tried for heresy and the other (Bill) who defended him in the church courts. I’m grateful for the courage and idiosyncrasies that left the more conventional, less curious church bureaucrats and the House of Bishops mystified. Bill Stringfellow’s own words of tribute to his friend Jim speak, in hindsight, not only of the Bishop but of the Stringfellow himself. May the both rest in peace.

William Stringfellow (April 26, 1928 – March 2, 1985), lay theologian, lawyer, author, social critic, alien in a strange land.

“The death to self in Christ was neither doctrinal abstraction nor theological jargon for James Pike. He died in such a way before his death in Judea. He died to authority, celebrity, the opinions of others, publicity, status, dependence upon Mama, indulgences in alcohol and tobacco, family and children, marriage and marriages, promiscuity, scholarly ambition, the lawyer’s profession, political opportunity, Olympian discourses, forensic agility, controversy, denigration, injustice, religion, the need to justify himself.By the time Bishop Pike reached the wilderness in Judea, he had died in Christ. What, then, happened there was not so much a death as a birth.”

I wish we were all that crazy.

To learn more about Bishop Pike, click HERE. For William Stringfellow, click HERE.

The first is from the late William F Buckley (WFB), whose Firing Line programme I’ll feature more of this week.  WFB was a devout Catholic and, like the majority of Americans, deeply respected the Revd Billy Graham.  I do wonder, though, what he made of Dr Graham’s final statement about there being life on other planets.  Note the mention of Christianity’s passing in this 1969 interview.  But, even more importantly, Dr Graham says that more scientists were arriving at a belief in God:

Now, in stark contrast, here’s a clip from Joe Pyne‘s eponymous show (more about which later this week) where he interviews the then Episcopal Bishop of California, the Right Revd James Pike.  Dearie me, what a fellow.  Pyne asks him questions which he throws right back.  Pyne rightly says, ‘Well, I’m asking you.  You’re supposed to show us how to get to wherever it is we’re going.’  Heresy in action at the 0.32 marker:

Unfortunately, the follow-up to the interview has not been digitally reproduced. Having said that, Bishop Pike appeared three times on Joe Pyne; on the last occasion, his wife joined him on screen. Bishop Pike met with a mysterious death in Israel soon after that final interview was recorded. He is buried in the Protestant Cemetery there. I hope that he made his peace with God before departing from this earthly realm. 

My point is — our modern-day error as seen through the Pike interview is nothing new.  In fact, it is quite old.  Did Episcopalians in the pews find Bishop Pike as irritating?  Yes, they found his views embarrassing.  Unfortunately, his legacy lives on today.